• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
information matters logo data driven innovation uk

Information Matters

Data-Driven Innovation in the UK

  • About
  • Contact
  • Sections
    • Analysis
    • Funding
    • Interviews
    • News Update
    • Events
    • Policy
    • Research
  • Newsletter

DCMS report outlines framework for increasing data sharing across UK economy

April 3, 2021 by Martin De Saulles

The UK’s Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) has released a report (“Increasing Access to Data Across the Economy”) from Frontier Economics with advice from Professor Diane Coyle (co-director of Cambridge Bennett Institute) which outlines a framework to help DCMS prioritise potential interventions to increase the availability of data across the UK economy. The framework presented in the report presents some public policy approaches to incentivise the private and third sectors to share data more freely for the broader social and economic good.

The report is a useful start to formulating policy in this area. Despite research on “information societies” and the “information age” going back decades it shows we are still at the early stages of really understanding the economic role of data in society. 

Future research needs to be integrated with our understanding of how public datasets are being used to drive innovation and social change. The overlap is huge and data flows between public and private entities should not be treated as separate issues.

The report has value but should not detract from the need to improve data sharing from the public to private sectors. Open data initiatives by national and local public bodies have shown promise but there is still much work to be done, particularly in terms of solving technical issues such as the wider availability of robust APIs for data access and consistent use of common data formats and metadata for reuse and findability.

dcms data sharing report interventions
Source: DCMS/Frontier Economics

 

Data sharing report’s key findings

The analysis presented in the report indicates that a package of effective interventions could include all of the following:

– improving knowledge and understanding of data sharing;

– improving or demonstrating incentives;

– supporting ways to address risk;

– reducing cost of sharing through data foundations (to help improve findability and the interoperability of data);

– reducing the (perceived – their word) regulatory burden;

– mandating data sharing.

According to the report’s authors:

“Addressing risk and reducing the cost of sharing are the levers that, based on our initial assessment, are likely to have a direct effect on the largest amount of economic activity. However, improving incentives and increasing knowledge of data sharing are particularly likely to have wide-ranging, indirect effects. Research on the effectiveness of existing interventions is very limited, but there is some evidence for the effectiveness of demonstration activities and for mandating data sharing where there is a clear case that this could lead to the development of additional services (e.g. current account comparison services in the case of Open Banking) or to increasing choice and competition.” (page 5)

Why government intervention is needed to improve data sharing

The report presents 3 categories for rationalising the need for government intervention:

– setting out a market framework that takes into account issues such as intellectual property regime and whether it strike the right balance between encouraging innovation and protecting rights holders;

– dealing with market failures such as providing incentives for organisations to share data where the broader social and economic benefits outweigh the benefit to the owner of keeping it private;

– to provide a way to prevent adverse market outcomes such as the creation of data monopolies.

 

Key data sharing issues and solutions

6 key data sharing issues are identified in the report:

– Lack of incentive to share data;

– Lack of knowledge about potential uses of data;

– Commercial, reputational and ethical risks;

– Regulatory and legal risks;

– Costs of data access / sharing;

– Missed opportunities to use data in the public interest.

data sharing issues dcms frontier
Source: DCMS/Frontier Economics

 

To remedy these issues, 6 levers were identified that the government can use:

– Improve knowledge and understanding of data sharing;

– Reduce costs of data sharing through better data foundations;

– Support new ways of addressing the risks of data sharing;

– Improve or demonstrate incentives for data sharing;

– Reduce perceived regulatory burden associated with data sharing;

– Mandate data sharing in the public interest.

government levers data interventions dcms
Source: DCMS/Frontier Economics

 

The report then goes on to map the data sharing issues against these levers:

mapping data sharing issues to levers
Source: DCMS/Frontier Economics

 

Supporting evidence for data sharing benefits

The report provides some real-world examples to illustrate its main points:

– inefficiencies and technical barriers to data sharing in the IoT – example of consumer IoT devices and lack of data portability between different devices from different manufacturers – fitness trackers from Garmin and Fitbit and home assistants from Google and Amazon.

– case studies of different ecosystems to test the effectiveness of potential levers:

  • energy smart meters;
  • APROCONE – platform for aircraft component design;
  • CityVerve – platform of platforms for local data sharing;
  • OneTRANSPORT – data marketplace for supporting mobility solutions;
  • HiLo Maritime Risk Management – data sharing initiatives to improve maritime safety;
  • The Weather Company – weather data platform to help improve decision making in critical sectors.

Across these case studies the benefits of dispersed data, lower costs for data sharing and building of trusted relationships between data users are highlighted.

Finally, the report maps the data market values relevant to each lever in total and by industry sectors:

market sizing levers dcms frontier economics
Source: DCMS/Frontier Economics

 

Data sharing report conclusions

According to the report’s authors, preliminary evidence indicates there is scope for government intervention to help data sharing outside the public sector. Addressing risk and reducing the costs of data sharing are likely to have the largest economic impact. While evidence is limited for existing interventions, there seems to be some evidence that demonstration activities can have an impact. The report and its findings should be seen as a starting point for developing public policy in this area. The authors outline next steps for future research including better mapping of the data ecosystem and its key players as well as more qualitative research around how organisations are currently sharing data. 

Commenting on the report, Professor Diane Coyle, co-director of Cambridge Bennett Institute and advisor to this research believes:

“It is important to ensure that the use of data in our society and economy is fair, secure, and delivers on its potential to help tackle major challenges. It should be acknowledged that data markets are complex and span an enormous range of sectors and policy areas; it remains the case that we do not have much data about data. The report’s approach of identifying levers, to overcome the barriers to realising the full value of data for society, is a useful way to address this challenge. The government, businesses and nonprofits will need to act together to maintain momentum and deliver real-world change.”

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Analysis, Open Data, Policy, Research, Spotlight

Primary Sidebar

News Updates

London’s high-growth businesses hold steady says Beauhurst

April 15, 2021 By Information Matters

Beauhurst has released its 2021 report on high-growth businesses in London and the overall picture is generally positive despite a year of COVID-19. In their first report in 2019, Beauhurst Read more

Doctify raises further $7.5m to fund growth

April 13, 2021 By Information Matters

London-based healthcare platform, Doctify has raised a further $7.5m in funding, bringing total investments so far to $20m. Founded in 2016 by NHS surgeons, Dr Stephanie Eltz and Dr Suman Read more

Tripledot Studios shows power of data-driven gaming with $78 million investment round

April 9, 2021 By Information Matters

UK gaming sector continues growth with $78m investment in Tripledot Studios. Rapidly growing mobile games company, Tripledot Studios, has consolidated its position in the UK gaming sector with a $78 Read more

Global IT spending to reach $4 trillion in 2021 says Gartner

April 8, 2021 By Information Matters

Worldwide IT spending is projected to total $4.1 trillion in 2021, an increase of 8.4% from 2020, according to the latest forecast by Gartner, Inc. The source of funds for Read more

Amplifi Acquires Award-winning, Warwick-based Data Management Consultancy, Comma Group

April 6, 2021 By Information Matters

Amplifi, a leading strategy and information management consultancy, has announced that it has acquired the award-winning Comma Group, an international management consultancy exclusively focused on connecting people and data to Read more

Footer

Sections

  • Analysis
  • Funding
  • Interviews
  • News Update
  • Events
  • Policy
  • Research

Company

  • About Information Matters
  • Contact
  • Newsletter
  • Our Privacy Policy
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2021 · Information Matters